Showing posts with label trading analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trading analysis. Show all posts

Friday, December 25, 2015

New highs next?

Subject:
Is the correction over at the August lows or not?
Last updated:
25.12.2015

H1
The rally from the low on Septemper 29 is the beginning of a new move to new highs.
H2
A new leg down will start soon.


Evidence
H1
H2
Comments
E1 - NYHL is showing some strength.
+
+
There is not enough strength to invalidate H2.
E2 - Short term macro indicators look ready to bounce.
++This does not invalidate any of the hypothesis.
E3 - TRIN 13dma has shown some weakness  on the latest rally.
+
+
Anything can happen given the TRIN at these levels.
E4 - Everybody seems to be bearish, expecting a bigger correction, me included. (Jeffrey Saut said it after discussing with many fund managers).
+
-0.50

E5 - The November rally has been an opportunity for participants to exit massively from US equity funds.
-0.50
+
A first month of massive redemptions seems to have followed previous bigger corrections.
E6 - Indicators of breadth have been very weak. For example 22d adv. It has gotten oversold only on the consolidation in December.
-0.25
+
This could be just a measure of the extreme bearishness.
E7 - Valuation looks high. Profits are at extremes and they could start to fall, especially if the slowdown in the % yoy rate of GDP continues.
-0.50
+
This looks like a strong argument against new highs but valuation is always hard to time.
E8 - The LT trend has been higher and has not been broken. The correction can be enough (12-13%) in an ongoing secular bull.
+
-0.25
Another leg down would break the rising trend but not decisively.
E9 - The Fed has started to hike rates.
+
+
The hike could bring some turbulence but in previous hiking cycles,  equities have been higher after some time from the first hike.
Total:
-1.25
-0.75




Conclusion:
H2 is winning.  A new leg down will start soon. This conclusion neglects the signal given by the generalized bearishness, but this could be ok because weak sentiment is sometimes leading and, also, if the new leg down is short, the bearishness could be exacerbated, producing a very good buying opportunity. The main evidence that made H2 a winner are the massive exits from mutual funds and valuation. Are they reliable enough? I think so. Note that classical indicators (like breadth, momentum are not useful - they will only signal an entry point)

Sunday, February 23, 2014

Falling Retail Sales and Falling Inflation


The series for Real Retail Sales shows a visible drop in the rate of growth, the kind that can be associated with a peaking business cycle, while Core CPI is resuming its downward trend, something that could suggest longer term structural weakness or just that the business cycle peak is farther away into the future.



Since the QE does not end until September given a $10bn tapering pace, the stock market seems to have enough time to complete another bull leg with 1900 - 1950 or even 2000 as possible target.

Sunday, February 2, 2014

GDP, Durable Goods and the Correction


Good Q4 GDP report with the consumption of Durable Goods still at respectable levels of growth but slowing down. In fact the annual rate of growth for December is significantly lower than the quarterly average. The behavior during the previous expansion suggests rates of growth will slowdown further.

Meanwhile, the stock market seems to have started an intermediate term correction (7-10%). The tapering is finally weighing in. Longer term support is at 1700 SPX:


Monday, January 6, 2014

New Orders Index- strong but peaking



I have written already about the fact that the New Orders Index (component of the ISM PMI) is at peak levels but this time I wanted to show it another way, plotted as a quarterly 3-month average against the GDP. I am planning to show similar charts for other important economic indicators in the future.The red bar in the chart is based on an estimate for Q4 GDP.

So, it is peaking but this does not mean much for the economic expansion. Even lower levels still represent growth.

On the other hand, peaking also means strong and the stock market and the dollar will anticipate the continuation of tapering. This means a larger correction for the S&P500 soon.

Monday, November 25, 2013

Intermediate Term Top

Here is a chart of the weekly S&P 500.



I measured all the bull uplegs and the intermediate term corrections. Generally, twenty-and-something percent uplegs are followed by shorter ones. Measuring from the June low, the latest bull leg has already been 16% long, so, since the market is up against the 1800 resistance, and already committed above it, I think a drop has to happen very soon. The following correction would be somewhere between 7 and 10 % long.

Saturday, November 2, 2013

New Orders Index

"Anyone who has studied markets half-seriously learns not to associate vigorous economic activity with stock market bottoms, but with stock market tops."

     Will Rahal.


Here is an up to date chart of the New Orders Index.


In the vein of the opening quote, it is hard to be bullish over the intermediate term given this chart. I do not think we can talk of a bull market top yet but a larger correction is not out of the question soon. Meanwhile, the short term looks good, with 1800 as next stop.

Sunday, October 20, 2013

NYHL

I have talked recently about signs of a peak in the business cycle, but the stock market is ignoring them.


The chart above is that of the difference between the 52-week New Highs and the 52-week New Lows for the NYSE.

The rally in 2013 was accompanied by a huge expansion of new highs vs. lows and this is still the case on the latest surge to historic highs for the S&P500. This often signals short term capitulation, but the longer term implications are positive for the overall bull.

For me, the latest bull leg has began at the end of June, after the 7% correction, and it is up 12% as of Friday. A 16% rise, which is quite average, would take the market to 1800.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

May 22 - new strength

After several ignored intermediate term top signals and new all time highs the market looks recharged. The technical picture, given some indicators for the intermediate term, is the same as it would be after an initial thrust at the start of a new bull leg. Divergences in breadth and momentum are all negated. It's time for a pull back but this is a buy.

For breadth, here is a  moving ratio of  cummulative advancing versus declining volume for a 1-2 months period:

I've marked the previous divergence that most of the time ends with a bigger correction, as well as the new thrust higher. I did the same for other two breadth indicators:

> the percent of S&P500 stocks above their respective 50 DMAs


> the 13 day EMA of TRIN



For momentum, I chose the average rate of change over a 1 to 2 month period.




This leads to the conclusion that the market is not ready for a 7-10% correction. I think it corrects for just 3 to 5 % into the 1600 -1620 zone and then resumes the climb. There is not much upside left as the bull leg is already 25% long, but a 30% rise already happened during this bull. This would mean a target around 1750.


Here is a weekly chart.



Monday, May 6, 2013

May 6 - the top is close ... again

This time it should be for real. The market is not too far from strong resistance and it has just rallied above the 1600 level. Given the growing weakness of the rally from November, a correction is looming.




Indeed, divergence of this kind in the 13d ema of TRIN has generally signaled an intermediate term top when the market was at strong resistance.

Monday, April 29, 2013

April 29 - update

The attempt to turn lower at the end of last week is failing. The market is strong and it will most probably make new highs before a correction starts.

The next few days can still be volatile because the market is overbought, but the ECB announcement on Thursday will pull the market higher in anticipation. Maybe it will also offer a good opportunity to sell before the employment report.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

April 24 - it's time for another leg down

The deceleration in retail sales has continued since I last wrote about it.



Meanwhile, the stock market has been consolidating near its highs. It is time for it to play catch up.


Especially as the daily chart has become committed to the upside yesterday by closing strong and above a visible inflection point on the chart and also above  the monthly resistance level at 1576.

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

April 2, 2013 - correction just around the corner

It's been a nice 18% run, but it's over. The market is up against strong resistance and the short term breadth is awful. Such a pessimist tone is not appropriate because the bull is not over, but, still, a 7-10% correction is just around the corner.


I drew resistance on the monthly chart above. There were many other important levels that did not manage to shake the market for more than a few days, but this is the ultimate level - the high from 2007. The market will most probably rise and close above this level and then turn lower in the following days.

Here is an indicator of breadth that shows important divergence - the 13d ema of TRIN.


The weakness of this indicator has been disregarded by the market in the recent past. In fact, I was expecting  a larger correction based on this indicator in my previous post. The big difference now is that the market has already risen by 18% and it is making record highs.


There are also some economic indicators that are sensitive to intermediate term fluctuations in economic activity. These are quite correlated to the market and they are suggesting a slowdown.

Here is the 3 month average of the New Orders vs.Inventories ratio,


the US PMI, which has turned lower recently,


the pace of change in Retail Sales, also turned lower,



and the pace of change in Employment (private payrolls)





Over the long term the bull is still alive. Employment in the US has been doing constantly ok and this should fuel the expansion at least until the end of the year. Overseas, The Chinese PMI has started to rise strongly and even the European economy is at the beginning of an acceleration phase.

Here is the Business Cycle Clock from Eurostat, showing the European Economic Sentiment Index (ESI), an indicator that leads economic activity and even the markets.



Thus, a correction that stays within the parameters of a bull market is a buy. It will probably reach the 1420-50 zone, but this level is just a wild guess for now.

Monday, January 21, 2013

January 21, 2013 - long term strength, short term weakness

The bull market is showing good strength over the long term, but the short to intermediate term is not looking very good.

Here are two long term indicators that have reached new levels of strength for this bull and are breaking the pattern of  multiple divergences associated with bull market tops.


> NYHL - 52 week new highs - lows



> the percentage of S&P 500 stocks above their respective 50 day moving average.





This suggests the bull may enter an acceleration phase, a fact also supported by the strength in employment and housing. These may have reached their peaks for the recovery, but no bull ends before these indicators have weakened for a while.

Here is a a rate of change in the unemployment rate and a housing market index.










Meanwhile, shorter term indicators are not so good looking. Breadth, as expressed by the 13 day EMA of TRIN, is clearly diverging with the market.


This kind of divergence signals a  bigger correction with great precision, especially when the environment is favorable, as suggested by the record low VIX...


... or, by the slowing down pace of change in retail sales.






Usually. a more important correction comes after a significantt level of resistance is hit on the long term charts. Here is the monthly SPX.



The market has just broken above the previous highs, 1474 - a possible level. The next one to the upside is 1522 - a bit far, but not unreachable.

Which one is it? My guess is 1474, but it's only a guess. We'll get a first clue during the following days. The market has committed on the daily chart above the previous highs, so at least a small correction is in order. The market could tip its hand on this correction.

Here is the daily SPX.


Monday, December 17, 2012

December 17, 2012 - target 1522

The market seems to have tipped its hand since I last wrote. It has strengthened up after reaching intermediate term oversold levels, as shown in my previous post.

Here is a monthly chart of the SPX.


The bull market has a tendency to correct at long term resistance levels. The next one to the upside is 1522.

A move to this level would also represent a break out of a rising wedge - not uncommon for this chart pattern.


The economic picture has  some points of weakness, but consumption, as a consequence of a continuing recovery in employment, is doing ok.



But this is a symptom of an ending recovery. Businesses have expanded their profits first, then they added equipment & software and then they started adding more workers, which led to higher consumption. Now, they are cutting back on investment and they will soon slow down on hiring. Here is a chart showing the correlation between capital expenditures and employment. Capex leads employment.



So, during the first half of 2013, employment reports will most probably get worse and worse. The market will ignore this for a while, since this means the Fed will stay easy, but the Wile E. Coyote moment will come, just in time for the upside break out of the wedge to fail, as it many times does.

Thursday, November 15, 2012

November 15, 2012 - on the edge, again

The drop below 1400 on the ES only resulted in a small bounce. Conservative longs averted the subsequent crash however, because the market did not really come to the buyers. Whoever chased it, got punished on November the 7th and afterwards. Patience is indeed the key to successful trading.

Now the market has reached the 1350 level, which I think will support at least another bounce. Here is a daily chart of the SPX.


The market tends to bounce after it breaks important levels. It did so after settling below the 200 DMA and I think it will do it again after closing below SPX 1354. If the market bounced a bit without clearly committing below 1354, then it would just be ready to break lower.

Certainly, the market is oversold from a bull market perspective. Using the chart below the average momentum of different moves can be evaluated.


Any lower than this for this correction and the market is entering bear mood again! It has been quite a whipsaw during the last 2-3 years from this point of view, but this means something too. The unprecedented volatility from bull to bear suggests we are at a big inflection point.

So, the question is whether this will be just a bounce in a larger drop or a continuation of the long term uptrend. My gut goes with the first, my system with the second. The market has nothing positive to anticipate fundamentally but it is oversold in a larger uptrend. I guess if this is the start of a bear, we will first get a bigger bounce into the end of the year.


P.S. - As I have written this post the market started falling again. If it does not reverse until the close, tomorrow will be a good opportunity to go long on weakness below 1340

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

October 24, 2012 - time to go long

Update: October 25, 1:35 pm - I did not buy the break below 1400 and I am sitting on the sidelines at least until tomorrow. The intraday reading on the cpc is at the overbought level while the market is falling - this usually is a setup for continuation to the downside.




The bull has paused a bit after the good news in September (economy expanding, the Fed easing further). The market usually does so as the news becomes undeniably good.

This being said though,  I think the market has reached the point from where it should start rising again. The set up looks pretty good: there are many who are calling for a longer drop from here, the market looks committed to the downside, the futures contract has reached strong monthly support, indicators are oversold and the economy still looks strong

Here is a daily chart for the SPX, showing commitment below 1425




  and a monthly chart of the December contract, showing important support at 1404 being reached



There is also a buy signal from the 13 day ema of TRIN, which has become oversold yesterday:


This market setup is coming in the context of a still strong economy, one that does not yet show signs of going into recession. Here is a chart of the pace of change in real retail sales, showing a still strong rhythm of growth.


The series has a bit more to grow before a slowdown in economic activity can be anticipated.


Now I have to admit that this bullish scenario is supported mostly by technicals (breadth, market behavior, support levels, sentiment etc.). The fundamentals that lie ahead are not very encouraging: the fiscal cliff and decreasing earnings.The market has chosen to ignore these until now. Will it do so in the future too? Who knows?

Anyway, the technical setup will lead to at least a bounce from here, so the risk is very low. A drop below 1400 on the December contract is a good point to buy. This may happen as the Fed makes its announcement today.

Friday, September 14, 2012

September 14, 2012 - the bear is dead!

For the third time this bull is rising from the grave to haunt short sellers. It first happened in 2010 and then in 2011. Bernanke's black magic (read: QE) is on the job again in 2012.

Leaving jokes aside, this is good news. Nobody, except childish permabears like Tim Knight at The Slope of Hope, craved a bear market and a recession in the current context of the global economy.  It could easily have morphed into a depression with grave consequences. The sad truth, I believe, is that this depression has only been postponed.


Here is one indicator that made me ditch the bear market scenario- 52 week New Highs - Lows:


It has reached record levels for this bull. There are also other indicators that are stronger than they should be during a bear market rally.

The spike in NYHL is a sign of strength, but also a sign of exhaustion for the short term. As it happened in November 2010 after the announcement of QE2, I think the market will correct for a few days. A drop in the 1420-1430 area would represent a nice opportunity to go long.

Supporting a coming correction is the fact that the SPX settled above the important 1440 resistance and then reached the 1460 level. Usually, the market pulls back after reaching such important levels.

The intermediate term leg should be fine though. The market is up only about 16%. A 20% move would bring it to 1522 - the next important level on the upside.

Here is a monthly chart of the SPX showing these levels.


Tuesday, August 21, 2012

August 21, 2012 - the concept of commitment

Generally, as the SPX commits beyond an important level, an inflection point is created. Here is how this principle has worked lately.


By commitment I understand a close or a strong move far enough beyond a certain level.

This concept of commitment is nothing else than the general contrarian approach so indispensable to any trader, applied for the short term. If detecting the crowd commitment over the long term is easier, doing it over the short term is a bit challenging. The method illustrated above is an answer to this challenge and it provides an interesting way of looking at market action.

Monday, August 13, 2012

August 13, 2012 - the top is close

Even though I am not posting as often as in the past, I will try to do it at least every time something significant for the intermediate term takes place.


The intermediate term bear market rally I have been talking about has approached the previous SPX highs. This was somewhat expected given the anticipated bounce in the economy after the spring - summer slowdown.

The rhythm of the rally seems to be changing. I do not think we will see steep 1-3 days sell offs anymore. Here is a monthly SPX chart with important resistance levels drawn.


The eventual top will take place as the market becomes overbought and breaks through one of these levels. A break to new highs took place as the market topped out in October 2007. It might happen this time too.

As to being overbought for the intermediate term, there are a few indicators that are close or even already there. This tells me that a top is close by, probably in the first week of September.

Here is the 5 day ema of the put/call ratio. it reaches the red horizontal line as a bear market rally gets overbought. It can stay there for a short while before the market turns lower.


Here is the average rate of change indicator. It reaches the purple horizontal line as bear market rallies top out. This indicator going significantly above the line is usually a first sign that the bear has morphed into a bull.


As these indicators signal a top and as the market comes above the significant levels I talked above, I will make an investment on the short side. Since this should be a long term turning point, I will keep this investment and add to it as future opportunities (read: bear market rallies) present themselves.

As for a target expectation for this future bear, it is hard to say. The 2009 lows are not out of the question as things could get really ugly. Even lower is also a possible scenario.

However, for the long term, it is better to target a process, a context and not an outcome. But I will elaborate on the different scenarios in a future post.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

July 19, 2012 - after the slowdown comes the acceleration

I started talking about a slowdown in the economy during spring this year. Judging by some indicators I watch, this slowdown has come to fruition.

Here is the pace of change in Real Retail Sales,



 and the CPI.


The stock market usually anticipates and accompanies these indicators as they move lower. This time was no different.

Simce the indicators reached the lower boundaries of their intervals of variation, the next move will be up. This would mean some good news for the economy until the autumn, but I do expect this bounce to be weak. Anyway, it will push the stock market higher and help lure in some imprudent bulls.